STUPID/SMART
The Banger Blog · a Stupid/Smart breakdown
New · 2021

The Unfiltered History Tour

Vice World News · Dentsu Webchutney, India

▶  Watch the spot

Third-party upload of the Cannes case film, so it may not live forever. The tour itself is still at unfilteredhistorytour.com.

The insight

The British Museum is one of the most visited museums on earth, and a large amount of what is in it was taken. Not bought, not lent, taken. The museum does not put that on the little card next to the object. The card gives you a date, a material, a civilisation, and the year it was "acquired", which is a very hard-working word.

So the tension is not that the story is hidden. The objects are on open display, lit beautifully, free to enter. The tension is that the story is curated, and the people with the strongest claim to tell it are the ones with no say over the label. You cannot get a rival plaque onto that wall. The wall belongs to the institution.

The idea

Run your own tour inside their building, without asking.

There's a new tour at the British Museum. But the Museum doesn't know about it. Yet.

An unofficial audio guide to ten of the museum's most disputed objects, among them the Rosetta Stone, the Benin Bronzes and the Parthenon Marbles, narrated by people from the countries the objects came from.

How it works

You stand in front of the artefact and hold up your phone. An Instagram AR filter recognises the object and pulls it out of the vitrine, putting it back in the place it was taken from, with the audio of someone from that place telling you how it left. Historians, journalists, artists and activists from Nigeria, Greece, Egypt, India, Ethiopia and Rapa Nui, in their own voices.

The craft detail nobody had to include: a live weather API tuned the filters to the conditions outside the museum that day, so the reconstructed scene sat in the same light you had just walked in from. Nobody would have noticed if they had skipped it. That is usually the sign you are looking at people who cared.

For everyone not in London there was a companion podcast telling the same ten stories, plus a site so the tour existed as a thing you could send someone rather than a stunt you had to be present for. Cultural researcher Shaleen Wadhwana was brought in specifically to keep the history accurate, which matters enormously when your whole position is that the other guy's version is not.

The stupid: stage an unauthorised guerrilla tour inside the world's most famous museum, name it after them, tell them in advance that you are doing it, and rely on ordinary visitors being willing to stand in a gallery holding a phone up at a two-thousand-year-old object while a guard watches. Pick a fight about colonial looting with an institution that has been winning that argument politely for two hundred years. And run the whole thing through an Instagram filter, a format best known for giving people dog ears.

The smart: AR does not need planning permission. The filter lives on the visitor's phone, not on the museum's wall, so there is nothing to take down and nobody to say no. The museum's own building becomes the venue, its own crowd becomes the audience, and its own free admission becomes the media buy. Then the second move, which is the one that makes it unanswerable: Vice does not narrate. The source countries do. An institution can dismiss a media company's provocation. It is much harder to publicly argue with a Nigerian historian describing how the Benin Bronzes left Benin City.

Why we like it

The steal: when you cannot get onto the property, use the audience's phone as the venue. Then hand the microphone to the person whose claim is stronger than yours, because an argument you make yourself is a brand opinion, and the same argument in their voice is testimony.

What we admire most is the restraint. There is no film of an actor being outraged, no montage, no petition, no ask. It is a guide. It behaves exactly like the thing it is parodying, and all the force comes from the gap between the official label and the unofficial one.

It is also a genuinely rare thing: a piece of branded work whose usefulness outlives the campaign window. Four years on you can still take the tour. Most award-winning activations are a case film about a weekend.

Results

3Cannes Grands Prix, 2022
~15ktook the tour by May 2022
~2,000entries in Brand Experience
1stIndian Agency of the Year

Straight talk. The visitor number is modest and we are not going to dress it up: roughly fifteen thousand people is a good turnout for a gallery, not a mass audience. The reach was in the coverage and the argument, not the footfall, and anyone claiming otherwise is selling you something. Mariana O'Kelly, who chaired the Audio and Radio jury, called it "brave, disruptive and engaged on a human level". The British Museum, as far as we can find, has never publicly responded, which is its own kind of answer.

Cannes Lions 2022: three Grands Prix

Radio and Audio, Brand Experience and Activation, and Social and Influencer, plus a Titanium Lion and a run of Gold, Silver and Bronze. Also a D&AD Yellow Pencil and four Grands Prix at Spikes Asia.
GPRadio + Audio
GPBrand Experience
GPSocial + Influencer
TiTitanium Lion
YPD&AD Pencil

Who made it

Client: Vice World News
Agency: Dentsu Webchutney, India, since renamed Dentsu Creative, with teams in Bengaluru, Mumbai and Gurgaon
Chief creative officer: PG Aditiya
Creative director: Binaifer Dulani
Chief innovation officer: Gurbaksh Singh
Historical research: Shaleen Wadhwana
Launched: December 2021

Sources

The Drum, the Cannes Grands Prix and the jury quote
Branding in Asia, the third Grand Prix
The Hard Copy, the making of, including the weather API and the visitor number
Campaign Brief Asia, the original launch and credits

The way in

The devices behind this one, from our library of ways in:

Use your rival as the stageLet someone else give the verdict
← The Banger Blog