STUPID/SMART
The Banger Blog · a Stupid/Smart breakdown
New · 2019

ThisAbles

IKEA Israel · McCann Tel Aviv, with Milbat + Access Israel

▶  Watch the spotMore

The first link is IKEA Israel's own channel. The man on the sofa is Eldar Yusupov, a copywriter at McCann Tel Aviv who has cerebral palsy, and this whole thing started because he was in the room.

The insight

IKEA's founding promise is democratic design: good-looking things that everybody can afford. Roughly one in ten people on earth lives with a disability, and for them that promise quietly does not apply. Furniture built for accessibility costs around twice as much and mostly looks like hospital equipment, so the choice on offer is a nice room you cannot use or a usable room that looks like a ward.

The insight that unlocks it is smaller and much better than "we should make accessible furniture". It came from Yusupov, and it is this: people with disabilities do not want a separate range. They want the same sofa as everyone else. The sofa is fine. What is wrong is that it sits too low to push yourself up from.

So the problem is not the product. It is the last four inches.

The idea

Do not redesign anything. Design the small parts that make what IKEA already sells usable, and give them away.

ThisAbles. Thirteen free add-ons for furniture you already own.

Files you download and 3D print at home. Bigger handles that a hand with limited grip can hook. Legs that lift a sofa to a height you can stand up from. An oversized paddle that turns a fiddly lamp switch into something you can hit with a forearm. A holder that keeps a walking stick within reach of the bed. Bumpers on glass cabinet doors so a knock does not become an injury.

How it works

IKEA Israel and McCann Tel Aviv worked with Milbat and Access Israel, the two big Israeli accessibility organisations, and ran a hackathon that put product engineers in a room with people who actually have the impairments, testing prototypes on the real furniture until the parts worked. It took roughly eighteen months from idea to launch.

The output launched in March 2019 as a website with free downloadable print files, a tutorial video for each add-on, and a physical accessible section in the Tel Aviv store where you could try the modified pieces before buying. And because the files are open, the thing travelled: designs were downloaded in 127 countries, most of which IKEA Israel does not sell into.

The stupid: you have a retailer whose entire economic engine is selling more units, and your recommendation is a free download that makes the unit they already bought last longer. You will not sell a single new product line. You are also handing your product files, effectively, to anyone with a printer, and inviting a group of customers to modify goods in ways your safety and warranty people were not consulted about. And the audience for a 3D printable STL file is, on the face of it, tiny.

The smart: the add-on strategy is the whole trick, and it is worth studying carefully. By refusing to make a separate accessible range, they avoided the trap that has ruined every previous attempt at this, which is that a special product marks you as a special customer. The customer here buys the same sofa off the same shop floor as their friends and adds four centimetres of plastic at home. Dignity is designed into the mechanic, not written into the copy. Commercially it inverts the usual purpose maths too: giving away a free part is cheap, but the part removes the only reason a whole segment could not buy the sofa, so the giveaway is a demand unlock rather than a cost. Hence the sales numbers below, which are the part nobody expects. And the open files turn a local Israeli programme into a global asset for free, because a design file has no distribution cost.

Why we like it

The steal: when a group is excluded from your product, look for the smallest possible object that removes the exclusion. The answer is usually an accessory, not a new product line, and the accessory is the idea.

Most inclusion work is a film about inclusion. This is a set of plastic parts that fix a real, boring, physical problem in someone's living room this afternoon, and it works whether or not anybody sees the ad. That is the highest bar in this category and almost nothing clears it.

The other lesson is about who gets hired. This idea did not come from research, an insight deck or a purpose workshop. It came from a copywriter with cerebral palsy who had personally experienced the problem and happened to be sitting in the agency. There is no process that reliably generates that. There is only a hiring policy.

Results

+37%units sold of products with an add-on, year on year
+33%revenue on those product lines
127countries downloading the files
13add-ons, free, open

Straight talk. These are the entry's own numbers, reported through the awards case, so they are the agency's figures and not an audited account. The download figure sits at roughly 45,000 people across those 127 countries, which is a modest absolute number against a very wide spread, and the reported 1,500% traffic lift to the partner NGOs' sites is a percentage on a small base. The sales lift is the interesting claim and also the one to hold most loosely, since a year-on-year comparison on a specific product subset has a lot of room in it.

The honest limitation nobody in the case film mentions: the delivery mechanism is a 3D printer, and the overlap between "needs an accessibility add-on" and "owns or can easily reach a 3D printer" is not large. Open files are a brilliant way to make an idea travel and a fairly poor way to get plastic into the hands of the person who needs it. That is a real gap between the idea's reach and its actual reach, and it is the first thing we would have pushed on.

And a credit dispute worth knowing about. The Israeli business paper Globes reported that the NGO Reut said it had brought the underlying concept to IKEA in 2016, worked with McCann through 2017, and was then dropped before launch and left off the credits. McCann disputed this, describing Reut's proposal as impractical and the working relationship as unworkable, and the final project credits Milbat and Access Israel. We have no way to adjudicate it. We think you should know it exists before you cite this as a case study.

Cannes Lions 2019: Health & Wellness Grand Prix. D&AD Black Pencil.

Plus Golds at Cannes and a strong run across the other shows. Reported Lion totals vary between outlets, from five to eleven, so we have not put a single number on it. The Black Pencil is the one that tells you most: D&AD hands out very few, and only for work the jury thinks changes what is possible.
GPCannes Health
BPD&AD Black Pencil
GCannes Gold

Who made it

Client: IKEA Israel
Agency: McCann Tel Aviv, McCann Worldgroup
Originated by: Eldar Yusupov, copywriter, who brought the insight and fronts the film
Accessibility partners: Milbat and Access Israel
Development: a hackathon of product engineers and people with disabilities, testing on real furniture
Launched: March 2019, Israel, after roughly 18 months of development

Individual creative director and design credits vary between the entries we found and we have not reprinted a list we cannot verify. Given the credit dispute above, that seemed like the right call.

Sources

D&AD case study, the insight, the hackathon and the Black Pencil
Contagious, on the launch and the partners
SHOOT, the Cannes Health & Wellness Grand Prix
Dezeen, the add-ons themselves
LBB, Eldar Yusupov in his own words
Globes, the credit dispute

← The Banger Blog